Qualitative Pleasure in John Stuart Mill’s Utilitarian Ethics: A Review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.63419/sabita.v3i1.68Keywords:
John Stuart Mill, utilitarianism, qualitative account of pleasure, higher pleasures, human flourishingAbstract
A significant modification in classical utilitarianism has been done by J.S. Mill in his distinctive distinction between higher and lower pleasures. In contrast to Jeremy Bentham’s formulation of utilitarianism, which emphasized the quantitative dimension of pleasure, Mill maintains that differences in the quality of pleasure is to be regarded as no less significant as it contributes to human well-being. The distinction has often been interpreted straightforwardly establishing a hierarchy between intellectual and physical pleasure. But such an interpretation would suffer from neglecting the broader philosophical framework within which Mill develops his account. The present paper re-examines Mill’s notion of qualitative superiority by situating it in the broader concern of individuality, human development, self-control and social responsibility. Qualitative superiority of pleasure is essentially associated with the exercise and development of human faculties, which in turn, contributes to individual and collective well-being. Intellectual and literary pleasure might be superior in so far as they cultivate imagination, creativity, emotional development and moral growth; but bodily pleasures, nevertheless, remain essential aspects of a good life. This paper also argues that ethical value of pleasure must also take into account the circumstances in which it is shadowed, the degree of self-regulation involved and the consequences it brings for the individual and other fellow beings. Thus it is finally held that Mill’s position retains the basic hedonistic foundation of utilitarianism, while developing a richer account of human flourishing.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.